Group: Members
Posts: 284
Member No.: 16889
Joined: January 15, 2019
I went lake Ontario last Thursday following a very appreciated advises from some people for the first time and got a nice rainbow. Was not able to take a good picture as I was alone and it was quite wavy for my tin tiller. However when I clean the fish at home, as usual, I open the belly to find out what they are eating and found these two inside. I guess it is sort of alewife. Even though they are quite smaller than rainbow or salmon I have feeling they should be very testy when smoked. Does anyone have an idea how to catch them in decent numbers? Is it possible? Thanks (Hope it's OK to post this kind of image)
Group: Members
Posts: 284
Member No.: 16889
Joined: January 15, 2019
Alewife technically and practically not minnow at all. Minnow by definition is fish from carp family, while alewife is essentially herring. Herrings are very tasty fish despite being small. We used to buy Mexican Gulf Atlantic thread herring here in Canada, small fish, but when smoked it was one of the best fish I ever ate (and I know what I'm saying). I'm not sure about Great Lakes alewife, but if it's possible to catch I would try. It is size of small perch and as you don't need to gut it, just clean its scale, so quite eatable for my family habits...
Group: Members
Posts: 250
Member No.: 4236
Joined: May 17, 2013
Personal cuisine preference aside, from what I've heard from other multi-species chasing friends of mine, alewife can be caught on hook and line, but it's not easy -and these were people specifically targeting them. You'd have a hard time catching enough for a meal. It is illegal to fish for them using a net, and they are not a legal baitfish species, so if you're ever caught with a bunch, you may have a hard time explaining that you're not using them as bait.
Group: Members
Posts: 284
Member No.: 16889
Joined: January 15, 2019
Fossil Fish, thanks, I'm aware of that. I wouldn't mind to explain even though in fact I don't have to. CO has to get some proof for any illegal action to charge. As long as having alewife in the possession is not illegal I'm Ok. The main thing: how to possess them....
Knuguy, not fresh, frozen. BTW I don't share the common persuasion that frozen fish taste significantly worse than fresh after cooking. I'm not going to argue about it as everybody has different taste ability and habits, but for me - keep fish cool, clean it ASAP, freeze it ASAP, handle and transport it gently, unfreeze it slowly and... to my taste it will be as good as fresh one. Again, not going to argue.
Group: Members
Posts: 5030
Member No.: 877
Joined: November 06, 2011
Not to argue at all but< IMO, it depends on the fat content of the fish. Oily or fatty fish such as salmon tend to lose their flavor quickly whereas cod, whose oil is totally stored in the liver, tends to keep for a long while.
Do you know of some place to buy frozen Atlantic herring? thx
Group: Moderators
Posts: 10137
Member No.: 2
Joined: February 09, 2011
QUOTE (Knuguy @ Jul 22, 2019 - 05:29 pm)
Not to argue at all but< IMO, it depends on the fat content of the fish. Oily or fatty fish such as salmon tend to lose their flavor quickly whereas cod, whose oil is totally stored in the liver, tends to keep for a long while.
Do you know of some place to buy frozen Atlantic herring? thx
A bit of a drive for you.. But Seafood Depot has everything..
Group: Members
Posts: 4985
Member No.: 67
Joined: February 10, 2011
QUOTE (Knuguy @ Jul 22, 2019 - 05:29 pm)
Not to argue at all but< IMO, it depends on the fat content of the fish. Oily or fatty fish such as salmon tend to lose their flavor quickly whereas cod, whose oil is totally stored in the liver, tends to keep for a long while.
Do you know of some place to buy frozen Atlantic herring? thx
Harold
The next time you are in Barrie, go to the "Centra" market in the Bayfield Mall.
This is an Oriental market that opened last year and they have a tremendous variety of fresh and frozen fish.
I bought frozen Anchovies there last year to troll in a teaser head behind a flasher.
Group: Members
Posts: 284
Member No.: 16889
Joined: January 15, 2019
QUOTE
Not to argue at all but< IMO, it depends on the fat content of the fish. Oily or fatty fish such as salmon tend to lose their flavor quickly whereas cod, whose oil is totally stored in the liver, tends to keep for a long while.
Knuguy, I was probably emphasized to much on "not going to argue" while it is interesting to discuss. You might be right, at least at the point that it depends on the fish you have. At the same time I found (and we discussed it many times in the family) that salmon here (in Ontario waters) is not fatty at all. I think that fatty salmon here would be only Atlantic salmon which I never got chance to catch. All other fish in here are not quite oily or enough fatty for me with exception of whitefish. I had read on some forums disparaging opinion about "greasy lake trout" comparing to Chinook salmon, but even lake trout (at least from lake Joseph, the only lake when I could get it so far) is not oily enough for me. I would be probably afraid to tell it publicly before, but now seems like I found someone how could share this: for me the most tasty fish is oily and fatty ones. I respect all fish I got here, and thankfully cook and eat them, but, to say honestly, Ontario waters are lacking good ones. At least among those which are allowed to catch (meaning exceptions like eel and sturgeon). In my humble experience whitefish is the best, ling is following (while its liver cooked and eaten separately in a special salad). All other even differ significantly in taste stay at approx same level for me. As for you question where to get Atlantic herring... we used to buy it 2-3 years ago in polish store Starsky for a very good price but I didn't see it there since. I guess you can buy now almost any fish in Chinese stores....
QUOTE
Every 2-3 years there is a spring die off of alewife that lasts for maybe 2-3 days
Longshank, Could you give me more info on this? It's not because I really want to get the fish for the table, but it is also interesting from theoretical prospective: why this die would occur? Thanks!
Group: Members
Posts: 640
Member No.: 4287
Joined: May 29, 2013
Eastern beaches and ashbridges used to have fantastic numbers of dead Alewives wash up on the beaches when I was a kid in the 70’s and 80’s. It was something to see!
Fishing Great Lakes
Fishing forum for the Great Lakes & Area. Fishing Reports, Current Ice Conditions, Fishing Tips, Discussions & More. Featuring Ice Hut Rentals, Accommodations, Bait & Tackle shops, Marinas and Fishing Guides. The best fishing in the Great Lakes!
Fishing the Great Lakes - Fishing Forum : Fishing Tips, Current Conditions, Fishing Reports & more! Fishing the Great Lakes Region