Sure looks like they should change the slot size so as to accommodate the sports fishermen to harvest a fish once in a while so we can enjoy a fish fry every now and then.
I think it is terrible that we are encouraged to harvest fish that are prime spawners. Every youtube video we watch all encourage the catch and release of bigger walleyes so they can spawn another year.
I am in favour of the "The regulation with the lowest amount of risk is
the 450-to-500mm fishable (harvest) slot size." 17.7165" - 21.6535"
Lowering the slot from 460 mm to 450 mm, with our fish catch history we would be able to harvest more smaller fish and release larger spawning fish. We seemed to catch fish that were just under the current slot size. Therefore if it was lowered to 450 mm we could enjoy a few more fish frys.
Lake Nipissing Walleye Model
https://files.ontario.ca/mnrf-rod-lake-nipi...-2019-11-13.pdfpage 63 - 64
"Given the high probability that the Lake Nipissing Walleye population will be declared recovered after the 2019 FWIN survey (Figure 17) and the current management target of 1.3BMSY, the best suite of angling regulations that may continue the recovery, if required, and possibly rebuild the population age and size- structure are: maintaining the current 460mm minimum size limit with 2 fish creel limit or changing to either the 50mm (i.e., 400-to-450mm or 450-to-500mm) or 100mm (i.e., 400-to-500mm or 450-to-550mm) fishable (harvest) slot size limit options. The regulation with the lowest amount of risk is
the 450-to-500mm fishable (harvest) slot size."
1. 460mm = 18.1102"
2. 400-to-450mm = 15.748" - 17.7165"
3. 450-to-500mm = 17.7165" - 19.685"
4. 450-to-550mm = 17.7165" - 21.6535"
I think that the fishery right now is being protected in the fact that the numbers of fish harvested is low because of the difficulty of catching fish at or over 460 mm. Some fishermen are able to routinely catch fish in this slot size because they have the knowledge, experience to where these larger fish are. I think us average fishermen have a difficult time catching fish in the current slot size. We are learning to catch these bigger fish but I still would like to harvest smaller better eating fish.